Q&A: Arenado on future with Cardinals, Hall of Fame case

April 20th, 2025

This story was excerpted from John Denton’s Cardinals Beat newsletter, with MLB.com columnist Bill Ladson writing this edition. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to get it regularly in your inbox.

In a recent interview at Citi Field with MLB.com’s Bill Ladson, discussed a wide range of topics from the strong possibility of getting dealt before the Trade Deadline to the chance of Hall of Fame induction.

MLB.com: You are off to a good start in the batter’s box and with the glove. What are you doing differently than what you did last year?

Arenado: I’m in a better position right now with my body. The body feels good. I feel like I’m able to repeat some things right now that I had trouble repeating last year. I’m just trying to maintain it.

MLB.com: What couldn’t you do last year?

Arenado: As you get older, you make sure you keep up with some fast-twitch muscle stuff, workouts and training. I tried to implement that more and maintain it.

MLB.com: I heard you lost some weight, too.

Arenado: Being lean has a lot to do with it. I probably lost five to six pounds. It feels a little bit lighter. I ate a lot cleaner. Laid off the carbs late at night. That’s helped me a little bit.

MLB.com: You turned 34 this past Wednesday. How much do you have left in the tank?

Arenado: I don’t know. I like the way I feel right now. I feel like I have a lot left in the tank. I feel I have a lot of good baseball left in me. I feel like I’m showing that now. It’s a long season, obviously. I’m going to try to maintain it. I think there is a better feeling to what I’m doing now. I continue to get better and that’s what I’m striving for.

MLB.com: You have a bWAR of 57.1, which is higher than Hall of Famers such as Pie Traynor and George Kell. Are you a Hall of Famer?

Arenado: I’m happy to have that discussion. I know people talk about it a lot more, obviously, when you are older and proven enough. You know what? I don’t know if I am or not. I feel I have a lot left in the game, so we’ll see at the end of it where I’m at.

MLB.com: As you look back, can you believe all the Gold Gloves you won and the production you put up at the plate?

Arenado: You don’t realize what you have until it’s gone. I haven’t won the Gold Glove in the past two years. Sometimes, when I look back on my time, I can’t believe I was able to do that, but I still want more. I’m still chasing more and I’m hopeful to accomplish it.

MLB.com: What else do you want to accomplish?

Arenado: I just want to be productive. I want to win. I would like to play and perform in the playoffs. I haven’t had many opportunities. But the opportunities that I’ve had, I haven’t done much. I would like to get back there and hopefully play better.

MLB.com: The Cardinals are getting younger. What are your feelings about the team and how good are they?

Arenado: I think the organization wants to see what we have. We are still trying to be competitive. There is a lot of development going on and there are a lot of players that need to go out there and show who they are. They have to continue to do that. We’ll see where we end up.

MLB.com: As far as the young players go, who has impressed you the most?

Arenado: Lars Nootbaar has been great. Brendan Donovan has been a stud. Victor Scott II has taken [positive] strides compared to last year. He is a totally different player. Jordan Walker is working hard in the outfield. He is getting better. Masyn Winn has a chance to be great. He has a lot of tools. These guys all have a chance to be good. It’s just a matter of putting in the work.

MLB.com: You are the veteran of this club. Do you think you will be with the Cardinals to guide these guys?

Arenado: I don’t know. We’ll see. We are playing hard right now. I think we are doing a good job. We still have to win a little bit more, compete a little bit better. Hopefully we can get on a [winning] streak here. If not, I would assume they would want to let these young guys run and go.

I know they don’t feel I’m in the way of that, but at the same time, sooner or later, you have to make a decision. I don’t mean this in a bad way, but I’m not part of their future plans. I’m older. That’s just part of it. When I say future plans, I’m talking about the next five years, plus. I understand that. Hopefully, we are winning so we can add at the Deadline. If not, I’m assuming some questions will arise.

MLB.com: Before last winter, all I heard about was your great defense and your production at the plate. But this past offseason was about the possibility of getting traded. Did all the reports about a deal bother you?

Arenado: It didn’t bother me. … So I guess when you know something is coming, it doesn’t really bother you that much because you are prepared for it. It’s OK. It’s part of it.

MLB.com: You had a chance to be traded to the Astros before the season started. Why didn’t you go?

Arenado: Obviously, I respect Houston with what they have done. They have been one of the best organizations for a very long time. At the time, I never said no [to the trade]. At the time, the Astros wanted a decision and I couldn’t make it.

MLB.com: What did you want to wait on?

Arenado: It’s fair to say I wanted to see what Alex Bregman wanted to do. I didn’t know how long it was going to take. That was kind of the gist of it. At the time, I had to make a decision. I wasn’t prepared to do that.

MLB.com: After your playing career is over, what do you want to do with your life?

Arenado: I want to golf a lot and take family trips. I want to go skiing and do things I was never able to do because of baseball. I would still like to stay in baseball. I would like to coach in college baseball.

MLB.com: Why college baseball?

Arenado: I like college baseball because there isn’t a lot of politics to it. There is probably more now with the NIL [Name, Image, and Likeness]. It’s really about winning. Every game really matters. If I can do it somewhere close to home, I feel like I could help give the things I’ve learned and share it with these young players.